09 Jan 2002 No farewell words were spoken No time to say goodbye You were gone before we knew it And only God knows why - Cynthia J. Mackenzie - To My Big Brother... You are always in my heart and never forgotten. You are a true hero and I am very proud of you. I love you and I miss you so very much. Until we meet again... Your Little Sister, Debbie carterc@earthlink.net

 

12 Aug 2005 Bob, Those of us that have been left behind want you to know that we have made contact with your family and have let them know that you and the sacrifice that you made so many years ago will never be forgotten nor will those whose names are on "The Wall" with you be forgotten. We love you and miss you. Classmates "1967" and fellow Veterans Tim Minnick Ed Minnick Mark Baker From a friend, High School classmate, and fellow Vietnam veteran, Tim Minnick tskminnick@msn.com

 

A Note from The Virtual Wall In March 1968 the 2nd Battalion, 4th Marines, provided the bulk of a Battalion Landing Team but was operating ashore in Quang Tri Province south of the DMZ. On 16 March 1968 a recon patrol located a large enemy force in the village of Vinh Quan Ha - and got into trouble doing it. Extraction of the patrol cost the lives of three Marines whose bodies could not be recovered. It also drew the Marines' attention to the village and a decision was taken to kick the NVA out of it. The following is taken from the 2/4 Command Chronology for March 1968: 17 March 1968:      Plans were made and orders issued for a BLT attack on the fortified village of Vinh Quan Ha. 18-19 March 1968:      At 0345H the BLT (-) crossed the Line of Departure and moved to attack positions. After a 12 hour battle which started at 0730, the objective was finally secured. The enemy was well equipped and fought from heavily fortified, mutually supporting bunkers and trench lines which were cleverly camoflaged. It was later determined from POWs that elements of 4 NVA battalions were located on the objective. Net results of the battle were: 127 enemy KIA's; 4 POW's; friendly losses were 17 KIA and 102 WIAE [Wounded in Action - Evacuated]. Many crew served and individual weapons were captured along with numerous items of equipment (the most significant of which was an HF radio complete with note book giving enemy call signs and unit designations). While the Command Chronology says 17 men were killed in the assault on Vinh Quan Ha, there are twenty men in the casualty database who have been associated with the battle ... several of the wounded died of their injuries: E Co, 2nd Bn, 4th Marines Sgt Robert O Bannon, San Bernardino, CA (Silver Star) LCpl James P. Achterhoff, Muskegon, MI (Silver Star) LCpl Mcarthur Hamburg, Enterprise, MS LCpl John P. Larkin, Port Chester, NY LCpl Gary D. Utz, Englewood, OH Pfc Elvin W. Gose, Cumberland, IN (Silver Star) Pfc Robert A. Martin, Logansport, IN Pfc Elliott R. Smith, Luna Pier, MI G Co, 2nd Bn, 4th Marines Pfc Andrew Springs, Rock Hill, SC Pfc Frank E. Weiss, Clymer, PA H Co, 2nd Bn, 4th Marines LCpl William C. Roberts, Boone, NC LCpl James E. Sprowl, Norwalk, OH Pfc Marshall G. Schaffner, Cataldo, ID H&S Co, 2nd Bn, 4th Marines Cpl Gregory K. Arthur, Tulsa, OK HM3 Douglas B. Parsons, Arvada, CO Pfc Robert T. Ferrelli, Salem, NJ Pfc Arthur L. Hawkins, Cleveland, OH Pfc Gregg E. Lavery, Syosset, NY Pfc Wayne P. Reeves, Mount Holly, NJ Pfc John C. Seaman, Spring Valley, CA The bodies of the three Marines killed on 16 March were recovered after the hamlet had been captured.

Contact Us

© Copyright 1997-2019 www.VirtualWall.org, Ltd ®(TM)

Last update 08/15/2019.